Alastair Taylor's List

1. Strong Bad (The Brothers Chaps) - Homestarrunner
2. Stewie Griffin (Seth MacFarlane) - Family Guy
3. Ren Höek (John Kricfalusi/Billy West) - The Ren & Stimpy Show
4. Skeletor (Alan Oppenheimer) - He-Man and the Masters of the Universe
5. Homestar Runner (The Brothers Chaps) - Homestarrunner
6. Eric Cartman - South Park
7. Homer Simpson - The Simpsons
8. Lion-O - Thundercats
9. Comic Book Guy (Hank Azaria) - The Simpsons
10. Cyril Sneer (Michale Magee) - The Raccoons

Mike Letts' List

1. Homer J. Simpson (Dan Castellaneta) - The Simpsons
2. Peter Griffith (Seth McFarlane) - Family Guy
3. Stewie Griffith (Seth McFarlane) - Family Guy
4. Penrod Penry Pooch aka Honk Kong Phooey (Scatman Crothers) - Hong Kong Phooey
5. Penfold (Terry Scott) - Dangermouse
6. () -
7. Stimpson J. Cat (Billy West) - The Ren & Stimpy Show
8. Moe Szyslak (Hank Azaria) - The Simpsons

Ben Calderbank's List

1. Homer J. Simpson (Dan Castellaneta) - The Simpsons
2. Shaggy Rogers (Casey Casem) - The Scooby Doo Show
3. Daria (Tracy Grandstaff) - Daria
4. () -
5. Duffman (Hank Azaria) - The Simpsons
6. Bender (John DiMaggio) - Futurama
7. Beavis (Mike Judge) - Beavis and Butthead
8. Yogi Bear (Greg Burson) - The Yogi Bear Show
9. () -
10. Jeff Boomhauer (Mike Judge) - King of the Hill

Brian Johnston's List

1. Duffman (Hank Azaria) - The Simpsons
2. Baloo Bear (Mr. Gilbert) - The Yogi Bear Show
3. Foghorn Leghorn (Mel Blanc) - Foghorn Leghorn
4. Stewie Griffin (Seth MacFarlane) - Family Guy
5. Raphael (Rob Paulsen) - Teenage Mutant Hero Turtles
6. Bucky O'Hare (Scott McNeil) - Bucky O'Hare and the Toad Wars
7. () -
8. Pinkie (Rob Paulsen) - Pinkie and the Brain
9. Batfink (Frank Buxton) - Batfink
10. Bender (John DiMaggio) - Futurama