Alastair Taylor's List

1. Beaker - The Muppet Show
2. Cookie Monster - Sesame Street
3. Wembley - Fraggle Rock
4. Sam the American Eagle - The Muppet Show
5. Oscar the Grouch - Sesame Street
6. Red - Fraggle Rock
7. Bert - Sesame Street
8. Count Von Count - Sesame Street
9. Animal - The Muppet Show
10. Waldorf - The Muppet Show

Mike Letts's List

1. Beaker - The Muppet Show
2. The Swedish Chef - The Muppet Show
3. Animal - The Muppet Show
4. Waldorf - The Muppet Show
5. Fozzie Bear - The Muppet Show
6. Sam the American Eagle - The Muppet Show
7. Baby Sinclair - Dinosaurs
8. Rowlf the Dog - The Muppet Show
9. Ernie - Sesame Street
10. The Job Wizard - Dinosaurs

Brian Johnston's List

1. Rowlf the Dog
- The Muppet Show
2. Grover (Super Grover)
- Sesame Street
3. The Doozers
- Fraggle Rock
4. The Swedish Chef
- The Muppet Show
5. Dr. Teeth
- The Muppet Show
6. Sweetums
- The Muppet Show
7. Fozzie Bear
- The Muppet Show
8. Cookie Monster
- Sesame Street
9. Sherlock Hemlock
- Sesame Street
10. Count Von Count
- Sesame Street

Ben Calderbank's List

1. Kermit The Frog - The Muppet Show
2. The Swedish Chef - The Muppet Show
3. Ernie - Sesame Street
4. Red - Fraggle Rock
5. Miss Piggy - The Muppet Show
6. Elmo - Sesame Street
7. Earl Sinclair - Dinosaurs
8. Beaker - The Muppet Show
9. Aloysius Snuffleupagus (aka Snuffy) - Sesame Street
10. The Two-Headed Monster - Sesame Street